Archives by: Gary Hoag

“For everything there is a season and a time for every matter under heaven: a time to be born and a time to die; a time to plant and a time to pluck up what is planted; a time to kill and a time to heal; a time to break down and a time to build up; a time to weep and a time to laugh; a time to mourn and a time to dance.” Ecclesiastes 3:1-4

“Mark C. Taylor has detailed the way in which the ideology of the market has made speed and efficiency primary virtues. The cost of such a rush is immense in terms of tradition, culture, memory, and our capacity for humanness and neighborliness. Speed goes with commoditization.

On the other hand, Carl Honoré has considered the quality of slowness that “challenges the cult of speed.” It is worth noting that the regulation of time in worldwide terms was accomplished in the service of the British navy, that is, in the service of power and control. Honoré nicely observes: “The telling time went hand in hand with telling people what to do.” There is indeed a time to hurry and a time to wait.

The tilt of the matter in our society is obvious. The frantic pace of overanxious 24/7 attentiveness and endless electronic connection requires that our accent in this added word pair must be on the side of slowness. Whereas speed is all on the side of commoditization, slowness is all on the side of neighborliness.”

Walter Brueggemann in Materiality As Resistance: Five Elements for Moral Action in the Real World (Louisville: WJKP, 2020), 59.

I am guilty of functioning along the lines of commoditization rather than neighborliness on many occasions. Productivity in that paradigm trumps people. God forgive me for living this way. This study is helping me.

I pray it helps you too. Materiality as resistance says that we will choose neighborliness over commoditization because we realize there is a time for everything and not everything needs to be in a rush.

The lesson for me today and anyone reading this. Generosity or neighborliness takes time. It’s not fast or demanding. It’s timely and deliberate. God help me grow in neighborliness.

Be careful, then, how you live, not as unwise people but as wise, making the most of the time, because the days are evil. Ephesians 5:15-16

“Now as then, keeping Sabbath is refusal to have one’s life defined by the production and consumption demands of a commoditized economy. In the keeping of Sabbath we, like ancient Israel, attest that our lives are not defined by or answerable to the insatiability of commodity.

In that ancient world, Sabbath broke the spell of production. In our world, Sabbath invites living in the new rule of God that contradicts the fatiguing world of things. Sabbath keeping is indeed acting as though Jesus is Lord of our time and
has decisively trumped the rigors of our schedule!

From that discernment of Sabbath, mature materiality has radically resituated all of our times with reference to the new rule of God. Thus the psalmist can aver: “My times are in your hands.” All my times! All our times! Not just Sabbath time but all our days.

Mature materiality consists in a willing readiness to recognize that every time is a gift from God; every time is an occasion for response to the holy time-giver; every time is an opportunity to act out our glad creatureliness in ways that befit the time-giving God.”

Walter Brueggemann in Materiality As Resistance: Five Elements for Moral Action in the Real World (Louisville: WJKP, 2020), 54.

What a word picture: Sabbath breaks the spell of production. “Mature materiality has radically resituated all of our times with reference to the new rule of God.” We find freedom from domination and the necessity to produce!

In God’s economy and within the construct of sabbath, we receive time as a gift. Our response shows our love of the holy time-giver. And every time God grants use comes into view as an opportunity to glorify our time-giving God.

Interestingly, we cannot steward time. We can only make the most of it. Why? No one possesses time. We can only choose how to use the time given us. Generous people give God one day a week.

In so doing, they do not lose time but gain it. The reset makes everything better, richer, and fuller. By including sabbath – on Saturday, Sunday, or some other day – we follow God’s design for making the most of time.

It will be a sign between me and the Israelites forever, for in six days the LORD made the heavens and the earth, and on the seventh day He rested and was refreshed.’” Exodus 31:17

“We may take it as a truism that Sabbath is the pivotal issue concerning time in the horizon of mature materiality. Sabbath is the defining moment in all time. All six previous days of the week move toward Sabbath time. It is so for the creation as it is for the Creator (Gen. 2:1–4a). Indeed in Exodus 31:17 we are told what happened to the Creator on the seventh day, when God rested. Our translations say that God was “refreshed.”

But the Hebrew word translated “refreshed” is the verbal form of the word for “self” (nephesh), that is, God was re-selfed after the depleting work of creation. So the human self is depleted or talked out of the self over six rigorous days amid the rat race of the predatory economy. The seventh day is for recovery, celebration, reordering, and affirmation of the human self. In Mark 2:23–28, Sabbath restoration occurs by eating. In Mark 3:1–6, it is by healing. Sabbath rest becomes elemental and indispensable for the well-being of the self.

Unreflective Americans want to abrogate Sabbath by endless busyness, by 24/7 electronic connection, by the practice of spectator sports, and by other preoccupations that numb the human heart and detract from the beauty of the human person. It was already like that in Pharaoh’s ancient Egypt.

In that regime there was no rest or relief from the incessant production requirements of Pharaoh. Then, dramatically, at Mount Sinai, Moses offers ten rules for resistance to Pharaoh’s ten commandments, ten guidelines for an alternative neighborly economy (Exod. 20:1–17). At the center of this new ten is Sabbath. Moses understood that resistance to and refusal of the insatiable demands of Pharaoh require attentive disciplines.”

Walter Brueggemann in Materiality As Resistance: Five Elements for Moral Action in the Real World (Louisville: WJKP, 2020), 53.

What might it look like for God to refresh, or literally, re-self each of us on a weekly basis? This brings into view a renewal for living, giving, serving, and loving generously.

Brueggemann teaches us that this calls for “attentive disciplines” which stand in contrast to the unreflective pattern of filling the day with “preoccupations that numb the human heart and detract from the beauty of the human person.”

This relates to generosity, in part in this way. The life defined by production (think: Pharaoh in antiquity and endless busyness today) and “preoccupations that numb” paradoxically becomes more productive with this reset.

Ask God what might need to change in your life (what to stop doing) and what attentive disciplines to add (to move toward refreshment) to enhance the overall generosity of your living, giving, serving and loving.

Do whatever He says.

Then He said to them, “The Sabbath was made for man, not man for the Sabbath. Mark 2:27

“The adversaries of Jesus, the Pharisees, had gotten control of their schedule. It is no small matter to get control of one’s schedule, especially in a demanding rat-race economy like ours. But actually the Pharisees had not gotten control of their schedule. To the contrary, their schedule had gotten control of them. They had only to look at the calendar to know what the particular day required of them, and what the day prohibited.

This domination by the calendar is not unlike that of my mother and many other mother-housewives of her generation: “Monday is wash day, Tuesday is ironing,” and so on. It is then no surprise that the Pharisees are vigilant about Sabbath day, when they sharply disapprove of the conduct of Jesus’ disciples. They know that what his disciples have done on the Sabbath day violates the calendar of prohibitions.

They have “plucked heads of grain” to eat (Mark 2:23), and their “work” by definition violates the Sabbath. Jesus joins issue with the defenders of the Sabbath. He defends and justifies the “violation” by the disciples. He does not say that Sabbath rules are bad or that His friends are free to do whatever they want on Sabbath.

Rather He asserts that His purpose (as “Son of Man”) trumps Sabbath rules. The disciples are to act as though the kingdom of God is present. And that means they are free to act and compelled to act for the sake of human welfare, in this case to deal with their own bodily hunger. On the one hand, against his adversaries Jesus radically redefines Sabbath. On the other hand, He reiterates the deepest impulse of the Sabbath command of Moses, namely, the emancipated well-being of the covenanted community.

That vigorous insistence is sharply reinforced in the next textual unit, Mark 3:1–6, in which Jesus, in terse fashion, heals on the Sabbath. He restores the withered hand of the man in front of Him. In the new rule of God embodied by Jesus, all times, including Sabbath time, are for the sake of human restoration.”

Walter Brueggemann in Materiality As Resistance: Five Elements for Moral Action in the Real World (Louisville: WJKP, 2020), 49-50.

Does your calendar have control over you? Do you live your Sabbath like everyone else?

Consider again this profound truth: “The disciples are to act as though the kingdom of God is present.” Notice what Jesus did on the Sabbath. He restored the strength of the disciples and He restored the withered hand of the man.

In Christ Jesus, the Sabbath comes into view not as day with restrictions but a day for restoration.

What might restorative work might you choose to do? How might your Sabbath living, giving, serving, and loving change from a day with restrictions to making it a day for the work of restoration?

I eagerly expect and hope that I will in no way be ashamed, but will have sufficient courage so that now as always Christ will be exalted in my body, whether by life or by death. Philippians 1:20

“Mature materiality lives in the awareness that we will die; our bodies (selves) are transient. The illusion of immortality in our culture is sustained (and required!) by the expectation that the next product will make us healthy, keep us young, and refuse our diminishment.

Mature materiality is under no such illusion and prepares for the dying of a good death. Such preparation, however, is not resignation. It is rather an act of hope, for mature materiality lives in anticipation of the resurrection of the body after the manner of the Easter Christ.

Mistaken spirituality has led to the seduction of immortality, the idea that there is something about us that does not die. Buoyant faith trusts otherwise; it affirms that the giver of broken bread is the Lord of life and the Lord of our futures.”

Walter Brueggemann in Materiality As Resistance: Five Elements for Moral Action in the Real World (Louisville: WJKP, 2020), 49-50.

The world presents an illusion of immortality. We must not succumb to this seduction. Or pour God’s money toward it. We must instead, prepare for a good death while living, and we do well to exhibit buoyant faith in the process.

Sure, we will someday die, so let’s live each day to the fullest and honoring God with our living, giving, serving, and loving. I am learning this from my parents as they age and face some health challenges.

I am praying for today’s Scripture to be true for them and every reader. For Christ to be exalted in our lives and in our death. The Charlie Kirk incident, of course, illustrates this. But I pray it be true of each of us.

Charlie prepared for death by how he lived his life. Each of us needs to prepare for a good death whenever it comes. A good death is not living long; a good death is a God-timed ending of a life lived generously with buoyant faith in God.

Just as a body, though one, has many parts, but all its many parts form one body, so it is with Christ. For we were all baptized by one Spirit so as to form one body—whether Jews or Gentiles, slave or free—and we were all given the one Spirit to drink. Even so the body is not made up of one part but of many. 1 Corinthians 12:12-14

“The image of body suggests that the community of believers is an active organism of complex parts, all of which are interconnected into a functioning living agency. On the one hand, Christ as the “head of the body” means that Jesus does the thinking for the body, that is, provides the guidance and assurances that define the body. On the other hand, the members of the body, enumerated as bodily parts, are interconnected and depend on each other for vitality and effectiveness.

Such imagery refuses the mistake that so besets much Protestant privatism, in which it is all about “me and Jesus,” as if other congregants as well as other neighbors had no significance for “my faith.” The imagery of “the body of Christ” at the same time refuses the institutional reductionism of the organized church that imagines that rules, protocols, and organizational charts constitute the character of the church. Such reductionism leads to struggles for authority and eventually to “guidelines” in the service of an imagined certitude.

Against such a temptation, the image of “body” means that all members, even “lesser members,” are essential to the full functioning of the body in response to its head. The claim is that we belong to each other, thus another dimension of the same fidelity that we have noted in our discussion of sexuality. This declaration concerning “the body” in the several epistles voices the character of the church as an assemblage of interrelated members who are connected to each other, who rely on each other, who have the capacity to “speak the truth in love” to each other (Eph. 4:15).

As the epistles develop, however, it is clear that this body does not exist for its own well-being. It exists to act out and perform the alternative world of the gospel in the practice of neighborliness that contradicts the anti-neighborliness of the old order. This body is fully committed to the work of Christ, relies on Christ, and is sustained by Christ.”

Walter Brueggemann in Materiality As Resistance: Five Elements for Moral Action in the Real World (Louisville: WJKP, 2020), 46.

I am safely home. Some statements are worth repeating.

“Christ as the “head of the body” means that Jesus does the thinking for the body . . . this body does not exist for its own well-being. It exists to act out and perform the alternative world of the gospel in the practice of neighborliness that contradicts the anti-neighborliness of the old order.”

Consider the connection to generosity.

We only grasp life as Jesus intended for us to live it when we follow His explicit, otherworldly, and counterintuitive instructions. Only those who seek find this alternative reality. Sadly most people rationalize disobedience by choosing to do the thinking (acting like they know better than Jesus) and then doing something neighborly (thinking they have done their part). That’s privatism.

No wonder the church as a business or a building appears lifeless.

Only when we act out and perform the alternative world of the gospel do we find life. Or as I like to say, we do not figure it out until we live it out. And when we do this together, we appear as a body. As we grow we need order and oversight, but the ministry is not done by ministers. That’s institutional reductionism.

God’s servants equip the saints for works of service to show the “lesser members” matter too.

We exhibit generosity, which is a fruit of the Spirit, when we act out and perform the alternative world of the gospel. It’s not something we do but something God does through us, as He neither needs our support nor relies on our service. We need to give it and do it. Obedience comes into view as the pathway to sustainability.

Is it time for you to abandon the anti-neighborliness of the old order?

Do not withhold good from those to whom it is due, when it is in your power to act. Proverbs 3:27

“As a result the mature bodied self becomes aware of the ways in which policy and public practice impinge upon the personal well-being of one’s self and one’s neighbor. Consequently one develops a capacity to “follow the money” and to see how the power of money, for good or for ill, crowds in on personal lives. This in turn leads to a capacity to recognize the crucial public issues that concern the rule and will of God, all of which have to do with the well-being of the neighbor and the viability of the neighborhood. The immature self is too often coddled by the church and remains excessively innocent about systems of power and excessively passive about the way in which law, policy, and corporate power may distort human personality or the ways in which law, policy, and corporate power may function in the service of the common good.”

Walter Brueggemann in Materiality As Resistance: Five Elements for Moral Action in the Real World (Louisville: WJKP, 2020), 45.

When we pursue maturity and follow the money we see how worldly thinking marginalizes and oppresses our neighbor rather than serves them.

My people in America demonstrate both immaturity and worldliness. God forgive us.

And the church does nothing but coddle people and remain passive. I can understand the ilk against Christians. Consider this famous statement from Mahatma Gandhi since I am returning from India and Nepal.

“I like your Christ, I do not like your Christians. Your Christians are so unlike your Christ.”

Christ demonstrated others-centered humility with consistent love of neighbor. And He made crystal clear commands related to money which I ignored for years. If we follow the money we see both destitute poverty and wealthy Christians.

I feel so angry about this. I wish I could not see it. And I think it makes God angry.

My American people have the power to do good and they do not do it. James calls it sin, and so do I! “If anyone, then, knows the good they ought to do and doesn’t do it, it is sin for them.” James 4:17

But my people revel in our ignorance. Pastors preach feel good messages rather than the gospel linked to money. This passivity propagates the problem. The rich get richer. The poor get poorer. And God sees it all.

Today, hear my post as a call toward maturity and a prayer for mercy from God.

As you choose to help rather than hoard and function as a conduit rather than a container of blessing, you will find yourself in the minority. You may even experience difficulties. But you will find joy and contribute to the common good.

What does moving toward maturity in your generosity look like for you?

Love the Lord your God with all your heart and with all your soul and with all your mind and with all your strength.’ The second is this: ‘Love your neighbor as yourself.’ There is no commandment greater than these.” Mark 12:30-31

“The bodily self that offers spiritual worship is the self given over to the well-being of the neighbor. Thus the mature body is in contrast to the former self that lives only for the self… The mature materiality of the body, however, will transcend self-preoccupation to identify itself to be a part of the body politic. The notion of “body politic” sees that the corporate life, the life of the public economy, and the reality of law and policy together constitute an arena in which the mature body participates as a responsible citizen. Unfortunately too much Christian spirituality is highly privatized, whereas healthy spirituality propels one into active engagement in the public domain.”

Walter Brueggemann in Materiality As Resistance: Five Elements for Moral Action in the Real World (Louisville: WJKP, 2020), 44-45.

Stateside many Christians mourn the news linked to the shooting of Charlie Kirk. What a tragedy!

Meanwhile, I am still in Nepal where society has collapsed but I am soon on my way home. I found that God wanted me here 4 extra days to rally the church to serve as the “body politic” and show their faith with accountability and generosity.

In every society, Christians who want to exhibit mature materiality of the body must act neighborly and not privately.

Faith must be lived out with consistency in public. And in places like Nepal where identifying with Christ can endanger your life and mark you for persecution, it is even more important that you demonstrate accountability and generosity. Let me explain.

When you live out your faith with love and neighborliness, it attracts to onlookers.

For example, Good Neighbor (Asal Chhimekee Nepal) is one of the networks GTP engaged on this trip. They do so much good with transparency that even the Hindu nationalist government works with them! What’s my point?

When our service is coupled with transparency rather than secrecy, our faith is welcomed and positioned to transform the public.

Even government officials antagonistic to Christian beliefs show an eagerness to work with Good Neighbor because they know they can count on them. That’s what I see. In Nepal the Hindus are not the enemy, they are future believers.

Consider Prakash Chandra Giri, GTP Curriculum Developer and Global Training Coordinator. He was born Hindu and knew no English until he moved to Kathmandu in class 1o to learn.

Someone who lived out their faith with love and neighborliness drew him to Christ. He then evangelized his entire village.

I love his zeal. It’s a joy to mentor him. But now I am headed home. Please pray with me that all my connection go well as I travel with many layovers over the next two days from Pokhara to Kathmandu to Delhi to Newark to Denver. Thanks.

Love must be sincere. Hate what is evil; cling to what is good. Be devoted to one another in love. Honor one another above yourselves. Never be lacking in zeal, but keep your spiritual fervor, serving the Lord. Be joyful in hope, patient in affliction, faithful in prayer. Share with the Lord’s people who are in need. Practice hospitality. Bless those who persecute you; bless and do not curse. Rejoice with those who rejoice; mourn with those who mourn. Live in harmony with one another. Do not be proud, but be willing to associate with people of low position. Do not be conceited. Do not repay anyone evil for evil. Be careful to do what is right in the eyes of everyone. If it is possible, as far as it depends on you, live at peace with everyone. Do not take revenge, my dear friends, but leave room for God’s wrath, for it is written: “It is mine to avenge; I will repay,” says the Lord. On the contrary: “If your enemy is hungry, feed him; if he is thirsty, give him something to drink. In doing this, you will heap burning coals on his head.” Do not be overcome by evil, but overcome evil with good. Romans 12:9-21

“What follows in Romans 12 is an inventory of what the new behavior in the kingdom of God might look like… Mature materiality focuses on the new behavior appropriate to the new regime. Mature materiality concerning the body consists in generosity, diligence, compassion, and cheerfulness, genuine love, mutual affection, hope, patience, and perseverance in prayer, hospitality, harmonious living and association with the lowly, peaceableness, rejection of vengeance, and generosity toward one’s enemies. This remarkable list of practices, taken to be quite ordinary for those embedded in God’s grace about which Paul has written, quite frontally contradicts the way of the world. The mature body is put to different use! Thus the bodily sacrifice offered to God is the self given over to the radical ethic of God’s graciousness now enacted as graciousness toward the neighbor.”

Walter Brueggemann in Materiality As Resistance: Five Elements for Moral Action in the Real World (Louisville: WJKP, 2020), 43-44.

“The mature body is put to different use.” This statement says it all.

Generosity, in plain terms, takes shape as giving ourselves to new behavior fitting with the new regime, the reign of Jesus Christ. As His living sacrifices, we live, giving, serve, and love in a way that “quite frontally contradicts the way of the world.”

I think God wanted me to serve and suffer with God’s workers in Nepal to help them chart a new course for the future.

GTP will host a special zoom called “Prayer and Next Steps for Nepal” in English and mostly Nepali. The time for Americans is 7:15am PT, 8:15am MT, 9:15 CT, 10:am ET, and for the work, sync with 8pm Nepal Time. Join here. Passcode: Hope.

The fellowship we have enjoyed and our perseverance in crisis has bonded us closely together.

Would people around you say your behavior matches or contradicts the way of the world? Ponder with the Holy Spirit how you would want them to answer and what changes you may need to make.

I am still sheltering in a safe place in Pokhara, Nepal until Saturday morning. Thanks for your prayers.

As for my personal rhythms, I will wake early tomorrow and rest on four flights to Kathmandu, Delhi, Newark, and Denver, getting home on Sunday midday. It will take about 40 hours to get home. Sunday afternoon I plan to rest from the rigors of travel.

I actually feel enriched rather than exhausted from travel. I think God made me to do it.

For life is more than food, and the body more than clothes. Luke 12:23

“Mature materiality must focus on a mature sense of the human body. Jesus’ statement to His disciples about the importance of life and body in Luke 12:23 follows the parable in which the rich farmer thinks His life consists in the accumulation of food; perhaps he cared more for his clothing and his appearance than he did for his body. The disciples of Jesus are to have their priorities straight. Food and clothing do not count for as much as life and body.

We may recognize at the outset that mature materiality concerning the body begins with responsible self-care. We know the routines and rules for responsible self-care: proper eating, proper exercise, and proper sleep, disciplines that refuse overeating, excessive passivity, and excessive restlessness. Good self-care does not specialize in drugs, cosmetics, excessive pursuit of consumer goods, or excessive online time that may detract from a centered self. We also know that social connectedness to neighbors makes for a healthy self in a healthy body.”

Walter Brueggemann in Materiality As Resistance: Five Elements for Moral Action in the Real World (Louisville: WJKP, 2020), 41.

What does responsible self-care look like for you? Do you have healthy rhythms related to eating, exercise, sleep, and service that enable you to live, give, serve, and love generously?

I appreciate how Brueggemann calls for “disciplines that refuse overeating, excessive passivity, and excessive restlessness.” God made us to work and to accomplish His purposes, we must care for our bodies and souls. We must have our priorities straight.

I discern that the reason God’s Word does not prescribe behavior relates to the differing bandwidths and capacities of His servants. In plain terms, we have different abilities and responsibilities. That means each of us must learn our limits and care for ourselves accordingly. Some look at another and say, “you need to rest more.” Others who function at a higher level might say, “you need to work more.”

Do you see the point? We must not prescribe rhythms of life and body on others but encourage each other to locate rhythms that help us pursue God’s purposes for each of us.

I find it ironic to write about life and body while sitting in Nepal where society has collapsed, lives have been lost, buildings have been torched, every incarcerated criminals got released, and people have retreated to their homes.

I could not get a confirmed seat out until Saturday so to try to survive I will move from a residential area that has experienced theft and looting to a more remote place for my safety and strategic discussions with GTP staff member, Prakash Chandra Giri.

How cool that the most common response to our accountability and generosity meetings was “timely.” Now that corruption caused the crashing of civilization as the Nepalese knew it, the Church will help rebuild Nepal with help from GTP.